There are scores of Italian restaurants in New York, ranging from fine dining to traditional pastas and casual pizza joints. After all, a huge number of immigrants from Italy landed here in the 19th century and 20th century in search of greener pastures. And they brought with them robust flavours along with expert pasta and pizza making techniques. Here are some spots to try when you’re visiting the Big Apple.
Business executives and well-heeled diners flock to Marea for their superbly executed Italian creations. It’s a reliable place that keeps crowds happy. Located at 240 Central Park South (just across the park), the restaurant is elegant yet unstuffy. And the service is warm and welcoming.
Executive chef Lauren DeSteno is responsible for the fine seafood-centric menu here. Start with antipasti of grilled octopus partnered with smoked potato, radish, pickled red onion, chilli and tonnato sauce. Or tuck into the perfect combination of plump and naturally sweet Nova Scotia lobster mingling with creamy burrata, basil and eggplant al funghetto. For the dinner menu, several types of raw fish and shellfish are offered on the crudo section.
What’s really sublime is the selection of house-made pastas. Recommended ones are the signature fusilli bound with richly flavoured red wine braised octopus and bone marrow as well as the Sicilian-style casarecce fused with jumbo lump crab meat, uni puree, basil and Calabrian chilli.
For mains you can choose to have whole fish or pan-seared dover sole among other seafood dishes. Portions are not too massive so you’ll have room for desserts like the signature tiramisu. The cube shaped cake is filled with luscious mascarpone mousse, espresso sabayon, chocolate crumble, and served with mascarpone gelato. The wine selections are substantial and include mainly wines from Italy, France and the US and a few more uncommon labels from Greece and Slovenia.
Find out more here.
Opened in early 2022, Nonna Dora’s Pasta Bar is a unique spot run by an 86-year-old first time restaurateur. At this small casual restaurant in Manhattan’s Kips Bay neighbourhood, you will find Addolorata Marzovilla (Dora) behind the glass enclosed area rolling out fresh pastas in the morning. She usually leaves before the restaurant opens at night. Dora uses pasta-making techniques she learnt 78 years ago back home in Puglia. Here, she offers fine-dining variations of the classic dishes she grew up cooking and eating.
Dora used to make pastas at her son Nicola’s restaurant – I Trulli – in the Flatiron district for more than 30 years. Nicola decided to close his restaurant to spend more time in Italy. But these days, he also helps Dora out at the pasta bar.
Different varieties of fresh pasta are handmade daily, and the accompanying sauces are not something you’d find in other restaurants in the city. Tuck into the signature orecchiette in rabbit ragu, or the maccheroncini grano arso (burnt what pasta) with duck confit, squash and greenhouse pea shoots. Another interesting option is the ceci e tria – fresh and fried pasta with chickpeas, tomato and pecorino. There are also gluten-free pasta options too.
Sit at the bar counter and mingle with other diners or if you’re with a group of friends, choose one of the high top tables. It’s ideal to order a few antipasti and pastas to share so you get to sample more variety of dishes. Besides fine Italian wines, there’s a huge cocktail list and about 10 negronis for you to choose.
Find out more here.
There are heaps of pizza places in New York. One famous brand conceived in Brooklyn is Roberta’s, which is most known for its hearty wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas. After amassing a huge following for its original Bushwick pizzeria, Roberta’s has since opened many outlets including LA, Houston and Nashville.
Worth heading to is their full-service restaurant in Williamsburg’s Domino Park. This light-filled outlet is a great place to get away from the crowds. The menu offers a range of pizzas from the basic Margherita to the famous Bee Sting with tomato, mozzarella, soppressata, basil, chilli and honey. Or sink your teeth into the Crispy Glover with tomato, taleggio cheese, guanciale, garlic, chilli, red onion and breadcrumbs. Aside from pizzas, there are also a small selection of dishes like the heritage pork ribs – grilled and smoked with honey, vinegar and togarashi.
Pair your pizzas with cocktails and a range of reasonably priced wines. And when your meal is over, take a walk along the waterfront to burn off some calories. Another new Roberta’s outlet will be launched in fall this year in Midtown, Manhattan.
Find out more here.
This bakery located in Broadway, Times Square, is owned by baker Antonio “Tony” Park, who has a unique background. Park who is of Korean descent, was born in Palermo, Italy and raised by an Italian family. He pays homage to his Italian grandmother, Giuliana “Anna”, who taught him how to cook and bake. Park, who studied pastry in Palermo, started working as a pastry chef in Italy and then left for the US to further his career.
Angelina is touted as the first Asian-inspired Italian bakery in New York City. The baked goods here are made with recipes passed down by Park’s grandmother. Pick up freshly made focaccia, pizza and panini with fresh ingredients. Or bite into the light and airy Roman-style pinsa topped with prosciutto and mozzarella.
There’s a substantial variety of sweet treats on display at the glass counter. A must here is the iconic bombolone – light and fluffy Italian style donut – with different fillings like Nutella and pistachio and Chantilly cream. Or check out the range of cakes, tarts, and authentic gelatos to boot.
Find out more here.
Read Next